Why I Think Judging Parenting Practices is Necessary.

OK, so I am probably going to get a lot of flack for writing this, but it’s coming through so strongly and doesn’t want to be bottled up anymore. I am not writing this for anyone other than myself, but if someone gets something out of it I will be happy. When I let out the perpetual thoughts in my head then they quiet down and I am a little more free. Even if everyone hates me after I say it. Here it goes.

I am a mom. Many of you know this (duh, The Feminalist MOM). Naturally, as a mom I somehow end up in a lot of mommy groups online. Truth be told, it is usually SO HARD for me to read so many of the posts in these groups. You see, an online mommy group is basically where a bunch of moms go to ask a million questions (“is this dot on my daughter’s toe normal?”), trade baby goods and complain about their husbands.

There is something that I often see in said groups that I have to speak up about, and this doesn’t happen only in these groups but in life as well, and I just can’t take it any longer.

It sounds something like,

“Don’t be so judgmental,” or “let people parent how they want to parent.”

Let me be clear. Yes, on some level too much judgment or concern about how someone else is doing something is only going to drive you crazy, and yes I drive myself crazy at times. There are absolutely certain things that parents should have the right to choose how and when and where they do XY and Z with their child. Absolutely. Then there are some things that are straight up not OK, and telling people not to judge you is a way that you don’t have to inquire about the harm you are doing. Instead, we have gotten to a place where we can pull out the, “mommy wars” card at anyone who is telling us that what we are doing to our children is not in the child’s best interest. Another very popular response is,

“What works for some people/families/babies doesn’t work for everyone’s.”

Again, yes, at times this is true. Some babies like being swaddled, some do not. Some families have both parents’ working full-time, some don’t (another blog post on that coming soon). So, naturally, things would need to operate differently in that household.

Then, there are some things where biologically speaking, as humans, we are not that different. In the cases of how our brains are effected by trauma and abuse, we are not that different. In terms of our biological requirements as human beings, we are not that different.

So where is the line?

What if I decided to give my daughter labiaplasty? Hey, I like the way it looks, and I read an article somewhere that it’ll help keep her vagina cleaner. Don’t judge me.

Oh and when I don’t like how my partner is acting I just get out the belt and whop him on the ass. Throw him in a corner to cry. Hey, he deserved it. He’s MY partner and i’ll deal with him however I want.

You get the point.

Some of the things we do to our children-our BABIES- we would never dream of doing to others. Do you judge child abusers? Rapists? Sexual predators? I hope you do. Judging these types of people is what gives us the discernment to say, “Hey, this is NOT right.”

What if I told you-and this is where I am going to catch some flack- that some of our parental “choices” and “rights” are merely socially acceptable forms of child abuse, neglect and sexual assault.

There. I said it.

Judging other parents for their decisions to modify their child’s body, leave their baby alone to cry in a dark room until they are purple and vomiting and using physical force as a form of punishment is not me being sanctimonious or perpetuating “mommy wars” anymore than judging and calling out a rapist is being a cock block.

I really done it now, huh?

We judge these behaviors so that we can make better decisions so that we can have a better life for ourselves and our children and ultimately, humanity.

Judging human behavior is natural and a way that our internal alarm system goes off when universal law is being abandoned.

“Asking someone not to judge is one of the most unnatural things you could ask. What you’re essentially asking the person to do is to act brain-dead and abandon their natural human faculties, which is itself unnatural as long as the person is alive.”

As parents it is our job to question common practices and evaluate if we are carrying them out because it’s a pattern and it is what was done to us or if it’s because it works and actually feels good to do it. The problem with so many of these issues I am talking about is that it is rare that people are consciously choosing them. They were mostly chosen for them by society and are passed down quackery.

” If you don’t know your options then you don’t have any,” and therefore you are not acting from a place of choice, you are acting on autopilot and acting from that place does not give you freedom to choose. You are not choosing. You are a prisoner in a sense.

To not question these harmful and trauma inducing parenting practices that have caught wind in our culture is to perpetuate intellectual dronery (if that wasn’t a word before, it is now).

We have to stop assuming that common practices are okay simply because they are common. Many of them are only common in our country, on our side of the imaginary lines. Do you realize that things we think are acceptable and normal here are BANNED in other countries? I mean, really, this is the only variable some people are using to measure if the practice or behavior is acceptable or not (is that most people are doing it). In reality there is no difference in mutilating a boy’s genitals than there is a girl’s. There is no difference in piercing a baby’s nose than her ears. There is no difference in hitting your spouse than there is in hitting your child. There is no difference in threatening and isolating an upset child than there is in isolating and threatening an upset girlfriend, except maybe your girlfriend has the brain capacity to self soothe and regulate herself, unlike a small child. Something we can only learn as adults if we were made to feel secure and attached as infants.

So go ahead. Call me judgmental and sanctimonious. Claim that I “must be so perfect compared to all the horrible moms out there.” I am not perfect. I mess up. I get frustrated and I have felt overwhelmed. I love gluten free waffles, okay?  Nobody ever said it was easy, but thinking it has to look a certain way makes it harder. Thinking and using methods and formulas (not the food kind) on our children only detaches us from feeling them in every situation. The only “war” on moms are the ones created by “experts” and other people who tell mothers to go against their natural instincts and cause harm to their babies. We are so concerned about the feelings and “rights” of the mother that we keep our mouths shut and “support” her no matter what. I will tell you, I don’t always support a decision just because it was made by a fellow mother. What about a child’s right to health, optimal development and bodily autonomy? What about how a baby feels when he is left alone in a room for 12 hours? We would be appalled if someone left a baby alone in a dark closet alone from 6am to 6pm. But a dark room alone from 6pm to 6am? Totally fine, but why? Their needs don’t go away at night.

I digress.

I am not anti-mom. I am a huge proponent in needing more support for mothers. The lack of it is devastating and in large part to blame for the bad decision making I am talking about. It is not totally our fault.

I am pro-child. Children deserve to be treated and cared for the way I believe nature and the universe intended. This doesn’t mean making sure they don’t ever cry or protecting them from all pain and failure. It means not inflicting it upon them intentionally and unnecessarily. It means being willing to look at all of our actions to see if that is what we are doing. Children are not sub-human.

“Children are not property, they are people; precious individuals worthy of love, respect and protection. Listen when they speak. Comfort them when they cry. Treat them kindly. Teach them devotedly. Correct them compassionately. Love them unconditionally. 

If we want the world to be a better place, we should start by being better to children.”

-Peacefulparenting.org

 

19 thoughts on “Why I Think Judging Parenting Practices is Necessary.

  1. Lia says:

    I could not possibly love this more. I made a Facebook rant about this exact thing not too long ago, but you said it much more nicely and eloquently. Children are PEOPLE and deserve the best we can give them!

    Like

  2. gnominn says:

    I don’t believe ‘nature’ or ‘the universe’ have any intentions whatsoever but I do agree with most of your points. As a species capable of empathy we’re letting children down. We’ve come a long way from believing babies don’t feel physical pain, but still dragging our feet on the path to acknowledging their mental and emotional distress. When a toddler shows that they’re tired, stressed, over-stimulated etc. by tantrumming it’s more than just an annoying facade they put up to make adults lives harder, they’re suffering. Punishing them for it is unconscionable.
    On the punishing note, hitting children while telling them not to hit people sends a whole confusing mixture of godawful messages. If hitting people is bad does that mean mummy is bad? Or do children not count as people? Or is the child you’re hitting sub-human so you can hit it but it’s not allowed to hit people? Or is it okay to hit people you’re in a position of power over? Or is it that you can ask for more self control from a child than you’re willing to demonstrate yourself? Gah I ended up saying more than I meant to but it feels good to say it somewhere!

    Like

  3. Michel Deslatte says:

    I have had to go through my own trial and error and i have had to stand up for my truth against family and husband because i realized that i was only following hand me downs and i wasnt into it anymore…it was time for something new
    I do have to say that you might want to check out other countries’ standards on punishment with children…you might be surprised how much more compassionate our families can be compared to the latter
    Good day to you (^.^)

    Like

  4. Agnes says:

    I get your point. I agree mostly. Just one thing, humans are seldom black and white. They get exposed to one thing, they somehow adjust and might start a journey towards more empathy. It’s a work in progress. Honestly, i think for the majority, it’s a matter of unlearning, being exposed and inspired gradually. The judgment that we are guilty of, is not the condemnation of choices, behavior, parental practices,… It is the quick fitting into good or bad parenting. It is the lack of willingness to guide into awareness, knowledge, choice like we would do for anyone in a learning position. Instead, we make them feel like a lost cause. A failure. The wrong parents. We assume they are either dumb or consciously harming the children. That s the kind of reactions that trigger the defensive responses.

    Like

  5. Laura Adams says:

    We need to make parenting class/lessons mandatory for all parents to be. I know this sounds harsh but my Dr. & Midwife offered them. It is time to get serious about child abuse!

    Like

  6. Lisa says:

    Can you provide a link or source promoting leaving a baby alone in a dark room from 6pm to 6am? I don’t know any CIO proponents who would advocate something that extreme.

    Like

    • FeminalistMom says:

      The reason I wrote 6am to 6pm is because that’s a general bedtime. People leaving their baby alone for the entire duration of whenever their idea is that baby should be sleeping. Obviously, that time period is going to be different for some people. Maybe bedtime is 7pm, I dunno. But many people believe babies should sleep for 12 hours so they put their baby in the room, baby cries until baby falls asleep, then baby isn’t taken out until it’s morning. Make sense?

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s